Saturday, January 11, 2020

Jain Monasticism

          JAINISM is pre-eminently a monastically oriented religion. According to Jain philosophy the goal of human life is moksa, liberation from transmigratory cycle of births and deaths. Perverted views, non-restraint, carelessness, passions, and activity are the five causes of bondage[i] and these can be totally eliminated by the rigorous practice of a discipline possible only to  monk. So great is the emphasis laid for on monasticism that to renounce the world and to become a monk is one of the prime aspirations of every Jain lay devotee[ii]. Kumar goes to the extent of saying that Jainism is simply a monastic organization, an Order of begging friars somewhat similar to Dominicans or Franciscans in medieval Europe, and that the Jain religion is purely an ethical system arising out of its monasticism[iii].

Origin

            There are various theories regarding the origin of Jain monasticism. According to orthodox belief, Jainism is eternal. The various similarities between the three monastic systems which have arisen in India,, viz Upanisadic, Buddhistic and Jain, have led some scholars to believe that Jainism was an offshoot or degeneration of the Upanisadic concepts.[iv]  But leading Indologists have conclusively proved that Jainism was a system older than and independent of the other two. Jocobi and Garbe consider Jainism and Buddhism as the Ksatriya protest against the class exclusiveness and ritualism of Brahmanism.[v] Others opine that Sramanism (Sramana=wandering mendicant) originated out of the blending of the concept of a celibate, disciplined and studious Brahmacarin, and the Upanisadic concept of Brahmavadin. A Sramana behaves like the former and thinks like the later. To Jacobi, the Jain monastic rules appear to be exact copies of the fourth Asrama, i.e Sannyasa of Brahmanism. Dutta and Upadhye[vi] think that Sramanism developed out of the non-Aryan East Indian indigenous elements which did not see eye to eye with the western Aryans who were not very favourable to monastic life. These streams of thought are sometimes termed Magadhan religions. It seems probable that the great wandering communities of Sramanas with the Jain monastic order as their heart must have arisen out of the blending of all these elements.
Historical background
            The founders of Jainism and its four branches- viz monks, nuns, men lay-devotees and women lay-devotees- are the twenty four Tirthakaras, the first and the last of these being Rsabha and Mahavira respectively. All these prophets were monks and, except Malli, who was a woman, all were men. Only the last two, viz Parsva and Mahavira, are historical. Parsva was born 250 years before Mahavira, and his order was prevalent when the latter was born. Parsva preached a fourfold religion consisting of non-violence, truth, non-stealing, and non-possessiveness, and allowed monks to wear clothes.
            Jainism as practised today is largely based upon the teachings of Mahavira who died in 527 BC at the age of 72. He was succeeded as the head of the Order by Gautama and Sudharma successively. Eight schisms occurred in Jainism, two during the lifetime of Mahavira himself.[vii] The final division into the Digambara and Svetambara sects occurred most probably at the end of the first century AD. During the twelve-year long famine in North and West India, a portion of the community migrated to South India. Years later when the leaders met it was found that  irreconcilable differences (specially regarding nudity) in their modes of living and conduct had developed between them.

 Eligibility for monastic life

             Jain monastic life is open to all, irrespective of caste, status and sex. However, to maintain a high moral standard and for practical reasons, certain qualifications and restrictions were imposed at a later date. Twenty categories of persons, such as the following, are debarred from monastic life: a child under eight years, an old person, a eunuch, a sick person, one devoid of limbs, a timid person, a mad or an imbecile person. Robbers, traitors, enemies of the state, slaves, servants, and persons in debt are debarred for purely social reasons.[viii]

 Causes for renunciation

                 The majority of people renounce due to disgust for the word and a desire for liberation (samsarabhaya-udvigna). Sometimes a woman may renounce when her husband or her son becomes a monk.[ix] Some embrace the monastic life after being impressed by the teachings of Mahavira. Besides these, the Jain scriptures cite many worthy and unworthy causes such as anger, poverty, enlightenment in dream, illness, humiliation, which may lead one to become a monk.[x]

 The ceremony

             Irrespective of the motive, the ceremony of initiation (diksa) is carried out with full gravity and seriousness. The ceremony is accompanied by great pomp proportional to the social status of the candidate. Particulars of the ceremony vary from sect to sect. In Digambaras, the aspirant stands before the Acarya bereft of all possessions including the loincloth. He is given a water-pot (kamandalu) and a broom (rajoharana) made of peacock-feathers to gently remove insects.[xi] Among the Svetambars, the aspirant is given three pieces of cloth, a rajoharana or a broom made of woollen tufts, a begging bowl, a blanket , a staff, and some volumes of scriptures. In the Sthanakavasi sect, a strip of cloth to cover the mouth is also given. All these paraphernalia make it easy to identify the monk’s sect. It also helps the monk to keep the Mahavratas [described below].
            A unique feature of the ceremony is kesa-loca, i.e plucking out hair from one’s own head and beard. It is said to have been performed by Mahavira and symbolizes the monk’s determination to meet the severe demands of ascetic life. This is repeated every four or six months throughout the monk’s life.

Mahavrats

            The acceptance of the Mahavratas, ‘ Five Great Vows’ is common to all the sects of Jainism and forms the most important part of the ordination ceremony. The five vows are:
(1) Ahimsa. Abstaining from injury to all living beings, small or large, moving or immovable. For the perfect practice of this vow the monk must be careful in his movements, thoughts, words, and the upkeep of his belongings. Jainsim recognizes as living being not only those having one to five sense-organs but also the elemental bodies (sthavara) in air, water, fire and earth. A monk is expected to observe ahimsa towards even these categories of living beings. So he refrains from such acts as digging, bathing, swimming, wading through water, lighting or extinguishing fire, fanning himself, walking on greenery, or touching a living plant.

(2) Satya. Truthfulness. This vow is fulfilled by speaking only after careful deliberation and by giving up anger, greed, fear, and mirth which may lead one to indulge in falsehood.

(3) Asteya. Non-stealing (literally, not taking what is not given). This is carried out by begging, by asking permission of the superior before consuming food, and by asking permission for staying at a place for oneself and for one’s fellow-monks.

(4) Brahmacarya. Abstaining from sexual intercourse. This is carried out by refraining from talking about, looking at, or thinking of members of the opposite sex; by not recalling to mind former sexual pleasures; by avoiding too much food, dainty dishes, and beds used by householders or members of the opposite sex.

(5) Aparigraha. Renunciation of all possession and attachments. This vow is strengthened when the monk refrains from enjoying sense-pleasures.[xii]
            All these vows are to be practices in ‘the thrice threefold way,’ i.e the monk must not transgress them himself, nor causes somebody else to do so, nor consent to others doing so, either mentally, vocally or physically.
            The Dasavaikalika Sutra adds a sixth vow, viz abstaining from taking the night meal.[xiii]
            These Mahavratas, specially ahimsa, form the basis of Jain monasticism, and have led to the formation of numerous rules, and regulations, as well as exceptions to the rules to deal with unusual situations.

Samitis and Guptis

            The practice of ahimsa is strengthened by five samitis and three guptis.[xiv] The five samitis prescribe carefulness regarding movement (irya), speech (bhasa), begging (esana), receiving and keeping things (adana-nikepana) and excretory function (utsarga). The three guptis consist of control of mind, speech and body. The tenfold religion (dharma) of the monk consists of forbearance, modesty, uprightness, truthfulness, purity, restraint, austerity, renunciation, non-attachment, and continence.[xv]

Parisaha

            Twenty two parisahas pertain to the troubles and hardships a monk is often subjected to, and which he must conquer by patience and forbearance. These include troubles due to hunger and thirst, heat and cold, mosquitoes and flies, nakedness, wandering life, uncomfortable lodging, illness, insults and abuses, want of things required, etc.[xvi]

Tapas (austerities): internal and external

            Tapas forms an important part not only of the life of a Jain monk but of all Jain devotees. So great is the stress laid on tapas that it is added to the triratnas to form the fourth pillar of Jainism. It is the mot important means of rapid elimination of already accumulate karmas (nirjara). There are in all twelve forms of tapas. The six external austerities are fasting, observing rules regarding food, begging, control of palate, mortification of flesh, and living in solitude. Of greater importance, however, are internal austerities. They are repentance, humility, service to the monks, study, meditation, and indifference towards the body. Each of these has a number of sub-varieties which are described in detail in Jain scriptures.[xvii]
Daily routine of a monk
            According to the Uttaradhyayana Sutra a monk is supposed to sleep only three hours at night, and must spend rest of the time in study or meditation.[xviii] His daily duties consist of study, meditation, repentance for sins, begging alms, careful inspection of belongings to avoid injury to insects, and confessions of faults. Latter canonical texts prescribe the following six obligatory duties (avasyaka)[xix] for monks; (i) samayika, i.e practice of equanimity through meditation, (ii) caturvimsati stava, chanting the praise of Tirthakaras, (iii) vandana, veneration of senior monks, (iv) pratikramana, expiation of sins, (v) kayotsarga, standing or sitting in one posture for a length of time, and (vi) pratyakhyana, renunciation of certain foods and activities.
            Traditionally the Jain monks lead wandering life, except during the four months of rainy season. There are no monasteries but halls (upasrayas) are built by lay devotees where monks can temporarily stay. There are elaborate rules and instructions for begging, for the manner of wandering, and for stay. During the two and a half millennia of growth of Jain monasticism, procedures for dealing with various degrees of transgressions and their punishments have been evolved. The Svetambara texts given ten prayascittas, or punishments the mild ones being confession and condemnation. The harder ones include fasting, penance, shortening of seniority. The severest is expulsion.[xx]
Church-hierarchy
            A candidate having accepted the monastic life is put on probation after a preliminary diksa called samayika-caritra. This involves vows to avoid sins and to practise equanimity. Such a probationer is called a seha, samanera or antevasi. He must prove himself worthy of monastic life and must show implicit obedience to seniors. After a variable period of seven days to six months, he is confirmed (upasampada) and given the final vows, the mahavratas.
            Therea is an elder monk, senior either in age or standing as a monk. This seniority is called paryaya. The next higher office is upadhyana. His chief duty is to teach the scriptures (sastras) to the junior monks. Next higher designation is the acarya. He enjoys certain privileges and must be a man of perfect self-control and monastic discipline. He must be endowed with the five acaras, viz Jnana-acara, Virya-acara, Chritra-acara, Tapa-acara,and Darsana-acara. He stands at the head of a group of monks. Besides guiding and controlling them, he is authorized to initiate and to confirm candidates.
            Gani is yet another post. He possesses eightfold ganisampad; ideal conduct, scholarship, physique, intellect, instruction, debate, organization, and monastic discipline.[xxi]
Units or church-groups
            To facilitate supervision, solidarity, and study of scripture the Jain monks form different units. Gana is the largest unit having common scriptures. It consists of a number of kulas headed by an acarya. No one is allowed to change a gana except for special reasons like advance study of a particular scriptural text. Sambhoga is yet another formation of a group taking food together. The most important unit which is even now prevalent is gaccha. It is supposed to mean the following of one acarya. Sometimes it is equated with the gana.[xxii]
Jain nuns
            Unlike Buddhism, the Jain order of nuns has been a distinct feature of Jain church from the very beginning. Mahavira had in his congregation greater number of nuns (nearly 36,000) than monks, and this state prevails even today. Like men, women also renounce for various reasons. Cases of child-widows becoming nuns are not wanting. Generally the permission of the guardian must be obtained. Even women must do kesa-loca.
            Nuns are organized under their officers. Ganini, pravartini, theri and bhikkuni are the offices in descending order of importance and seniority. A young nun not yet confirmed is called ksullika. All the offices of nuns are subordinate to the offices of monks. This subordination is so supreme that a monk of three years’ standing could become the upadhyaya of a nun of thirty years’ standing.
            Like monks, nuns too lead a wandering life and their rules and regulations are similar to those of monks. A spotless life and practice of rigorous discipline are expected, and punishments for transgressions are severe. Monks and nuns are not allowed to stay under the same shelter except during calamities or under unforseen circumstances. There are some special rules which help to maintain a pure and unharrassed life of nuns in the society.[xxiii]

Conclusion

            One of the noteworthy features of Jainism is the close link which exits between its lay and monastic communities. Jains as a whole are proud of the austere life-style of their mendicants. The solidarity of the Jain social structure too depends to a large extent upon the great moral authority exercised by their austere monks and nuns. The moral decline of the holy men, therefore, becomes a cause of concern for the whole society. Under such situations, the learned among the laity are free to point out the imperfections in the conduct of even the monks. It is noteworthy that some of the important reform movements in Jainism were initiated by enlightened lay-devotees.
            There are approximately 8,000 Jain monks and nuns in India today, belonging to some twenty-five different sects. Of the various non-Vedic Sramana traditions, Jainism alone has survived in India till today against heavy odds. This speaks volumes for its vitality and adaptability.


References:



[i] Tattvartha-Sutra ( of Umasvati). Text with Hindi exposition (following Svetambara tradition) by Sukhalalji Sanghvi. Jain Samskriti Samsodhana Mandala, 1952, 2nd Ed. VIII, i.
[ii] Thananga Sutra, in `Angasuttani, Jain Visva Bharati, lanadu, Vikram Samvat 2031, III, 4:210.
[iii] Prof. Kumar, J.A. quoted by Deo S.B. in History of Jain Monachism, from inscriptions and literature. Deccan College Research Institute, Poona 6. 1956. P.47
[iv] Deo S.B. History of Jain Monachism, op. Cit. P.52
[v] Ibid; p.48
[vi] Ibid; p.54
[vii] Ibid; p.78
[viii] Thananga Sutra, Commentary by Abhyyadev, quoted by Deo S.B. in History of Jain Monachism, op. Cit; p.140
[ix] Deo; S.B; op. cit; p.140
[x] Thananga Sutra, op. cit; X, 15.
[xi] Jaini P.S; The Jain Path of Purification, Motilal Banarsidass, Varanasi, 1979 p. 244
[xii] Acaranga Sutra, tr. By H.Jacobi, in Jaina Sutras, 1:1 –213, Sacred Books of the East, 1980, Vol. 22, 15, i.v.(condensed).
[xiii] (a) Dasa-Vaikalika Sutra, Tr. By Kastur Chand Lalvani, Motilal Banarsidass, Delhi, 1973, Ch. 4 (b) Samana Suttam, Sarva Seva Sangha, Varanasi, 1975, verse 382
[xiv] (a) Uttaradhyayana Sutra, tr. By H. Jacobi in Jain Sutras, 2:1-232. Sacred Books of the East, Vol. 45, Ch. XXIV. (b) Samana Suttam, op. cit; verse 384
[xv] (a) Tattvarha Sutra, op. cit; IX-6, (b) Samana Suttam, op. cit; 84
[xvi] Uttaradhyayana Sutra, Ch. II
[xvii] Ibid; Ch. XXX
[xviii] Ibid; Ch. XXXVI
[xix] Samana Suttam; op. cit. 424
[xx] Deo S.B. Jaina Monastic Jurisprudence, Jaina Cultural Research Soceity, Banaras, 1960.  p. 39
[xxi] Ibid; p. 22
[xxii] Ibid; p.33
[xxiii] Ibid; p. 27